New York, N.Y. — It was a late October evening in Portland when the Proud Boys descended on the city, waving flags, chanting slogans, and flashing their signature black-and-yellow insignia. Officially labeled as a “Western chauvinist” organization, the group had grown emboldened in recent years, leveraging political polarization and misinformation to position themselves as defenders of American values. But beneath their patriotic veneer lay a dangerous ideology, one that directly threatened the very principles of freedom, equality, and democracy that define America.
The Roots of Their Hatred
At its core, the Proud Boys are fueled by a toxic mix of white supremacy, hypermasculinity, and anti-democratic beliefs. While they deny being a hate group, their rhetoric and actions tell a different story. Inflammatory statements against immigrants, minorities, and LGBTQ+ individuals have become commonplace in their gatherings and online forums.
One particularly troubling aspect of their ideology is their overt hostility toward the LGBTQ+ community. Members have been documented promoting homophobic slurs and supporting discriminatory policies. During a rally in Orlando, Florida—just miles from the site of the Pulse nightclub massacre—the Proud Boys openly mocked the LGBTQ+ community, holding signs that read, “No More Gay Agenda” and chanting hateful slogans. Their actions were a chilling reminder of the violence and intolerance that the LGBTQ+ community continues to face.
From Words to Violence
The danger posed by the Proud Boys goes far beyond words. Time and again, the group has demonstrated its willingness to resort to violence to achieve its goals. They played a central role in the January 6th insurrection at the U.S. Capitol, with several members later convicted of seditious conspiracy. The group’s coordinated attacks on law enforcement and elected officials that day revealed their anti-American core: an outright rejection of democratic processes and the rule of law.
In their minds, America isn’t a land of diverse people and ideas—it’s a battlefield where only their vision of dominance and exclusion should prevail. This perspective not only endangers marginalized communities but also threatens the stability of the nation itself.
The LGBTQ+ Community as a Target
The Proud Boys have increasingly targeted drag shows, pride events, and LGBTQ+ gatherings under the guise of protecting children or promoting traditional values. These actions, often organized online, have resulted in violent confrontations and created an atmosphere of fear for LGBTQ+ individuals and their allies.
In one widely publicized incident in 2024, a group of Proud Boys disrupted a drag story hour at a public library in San Francisco, hurling insults and attempting to intimidate attendees. Although local police intervened, the event left many questioning how such open hostility could persist in a nation that claims to value freedom and equality.
This isn’t just about ideological opposition—it’s about creating a climate of fear. For LGBTQ+ Americans, the Proud Boys’ actions serve as a stark reminder that hate remains a potent and dangerous force, one that seeks to undo decades of progress.
An Existential Threat to Democracy
What makes the Proud Boys uniquely dangerous isn’t just their hatred but their explicit goal of dismantling democratic institutions. They actively recruit disillusioned Americans, preying on economic anxiety and cultural grievances to swell their ranks. With their penchant for violence and disdain for democratic norms, they represent a clear and present danger to the United States.
Former FBI agents have warned that groups like the Proud Boys are leveraging online platforms to spread conspiracy theories and recruit young men. Their rhetoric often mirrors that of authoritarian movements, blending nationalism with a rejection of pluralism.
Confronting the Threat
Addressing the threat posed by the Proud Boys requires a multifaceted approach. First, law enforcement agencies must continue to treat domestic extremism as a top priority, investigating and prosecuting violent actors within the group. Second, policymakers and community leaders must work to counter the narratives of hate and division that fuel the Proud Boys’ ideology.
Education also plays a critical role. Teaching young Americans about the dangers of extremism, the value of inclusivity, and the importance of democratic institutions can help inoculate future generations against the group’s toxic message.
A Call to Action
The Proud Boys represent the antithesis of what America aspires to be: a nation of liberty, equality, and justice for all. Their actions and beliefs are not just anti-LGBTQ+ or anti-minority—they are fundamentally anti-American.
If left unchecked, the group’s influence will continue to grow, undermining the country’s democratic foundations and jeopardizing the safety of marginalized communities. But by standing united against hate and extremism, Americans can ensure that the values of freedom and equality prevail, safeguarding the nation’s future for generations to come.
The Proud Boys: A Growing Threat to America’s Ideals (Jan. 25, 2025)
Discover more from The Stewardship Report
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
